Property

Court decision a win for services dealing with noise complaints from neighbours

Apr 28, 2020

Save

Many early childhood education and care (ECEC) services have, at one time or another, been on the receiving end of a complaint from a neighbour, or group of neighbours, in relation to noise made by children playing in the yards of the service.

This is perhaps becoming more prevalent with the advent of mixed use spaces, where children’s services are designed and built to share space with commercial and residential facilities, as was a recent case in Brisbane, where Brisbane City Council and Northern Properties Pty Ltd contested a mixed-use development application which the council had rejected.

Northern Properties appealed against a decision of the Brisbane City Council to refuse a mixed use development application over land located at Dalmarnock Street, Enoggera. The application put to Council was for the development of a centre catering for 106 children on the ground floor of a building which would also house 19 apartments on two levels above the centre, and was contentious within the local community.

Initially the Council rejected the application, saying that the development would result in an unacceptable noise impact to residents of the apartments, and would cater for more than a local community facility need, both of which are at odds with the councils city plan.

The case was brought before the Planning And Environment Court Of Queensland, who held that the Council's decision to refuse the application be set aside and that the Council instead put forward a draft suite of conditions relating to the development.

Noise impacts are to be expected, Court findsUsing evidence tendered from two acoustic experts, it was found that five of the nineteen apartments would be subject to noise over and above the noise limit prescribed by Performance Outcome PO10 of the Childcare centre code in the City Plan.

However, in an usual twist, despite the development not meeting PO10 for those five apartments, the Court found that the development does comply with the relevant acceptable outcomes in respect of Performance Outcome PO10 overall, because the noise coming from the childcare component of the development “falls within the range of impacts reasonably expected by the Multiple Dwelling Component of the Development” for the following reasons:

the characteristics of the noise, including the type, scale and area affected;
the time that the noise is generated and its duration;
the knowledge of the presence of the Childcare Component.

Basically, because those purchasing the apartments would be aware of the presence of the centre in the building, they could not therefore have “an unassailable expectation that they will not be affected on their balcony by the noise generated by the Childcare Component of the same development”.

The Court was ultimately satisfied that the development would represent “a balanced decision in the public interest” setting aside the decision made by the Council. The finding may be of use and interest to those seeking to create similar developments in residential areas.

Information for this story was supported by commentary published by law firm Colin Biggers & Paisley for general information purposes only, and should not be relied on as specific advice.

To access the commentary provided by Colin Biggers and Paisley, please see here. A full transcript of the case may be found here.

Don’t miss a thing

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

A modern high-performing G8 Childcare Centre in Kelso has been listed for sale through CBRE's Michael Vanstone and Marcello Caspani-Muto.

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Access to quality early childhood education and care (ECEC) is central to children’s development, family wellbeing and community prosperity. In a significant joint commitment, the Albanese and Malinauskas governments have announced a major expansion of early learning infrastructure in regional South Australia, delivering new and expanded services where families need them most.

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

A newly completed childcare centre in Sydney’s south-west has sold for $11.5 million reflecting a 5.26 per cent yield highlighting continued investor demand for defensive assets with long-term income security.

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

A South Australian freehold early learning centre at 381–387 Prospect Road, Blair Athol has been reported as sold and settled through XCommercial Melbourne in conjunction with CBRE. Separate property reporting states the site was sold to Sydney operator Bright Steps for $7.843 million. For ECEC leaders, the story highlights a 2026 reality: premises transactions sit alongside child safety and governance obligations, approved providers need documented due diligence on physical environment upkeep (Regulation 103), historical compliance actions, and readiness-to-operate systems.

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Families in the City of Greater Geelong can lodge expressions of interest for four new kindergartens scheduled to open in Term 1, 2026, expanding local access to sessional kindergarten as communities continue to grow.

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

A modern high-performing G8 Childcare Centre in Kelso has been listed for sale through CBRE's Michael Vanstone and Marcello Caspani-Muto.

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Don’t miss a thing

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

Property

Economics

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

Affordability & Accessibility

Property

Report Summaries

Supply & Demand

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Affordability & Accessibility

Property

Report Summaries

Supply & Demand

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

Affordability & Accessibility

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

Affordability & Accessibility

Property

Supply & Demand

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Regional confidence: $6.5M sale of Bendigo childcare centre sets the tone for 2026

Fiona Alston

Jan 13, 2026

New public preschools break ground in Macquarie Fields and Ingleburn

Economics

Affordability & Accessibility

Property

Supply & Demand

New public preschools break ground in Macquarie Fields and Ingleburn

Fiona Alston

Jan 07, 2026

Early childhood education assets continue to attract strong investor interest in record-breaking $151m Burgess Rawson from CBRE auction

Affordability & Accessibility

Early childhood education assets continue to attract strong investor interest in record-breaking $151m Burgess Rawson from CBRE auction

Fiona Alston

Dec 16, 2025

Community-led early learning service opens in Alice Springs to support First Nations children

Affordability & Accessibility

Community-led early learning service opens in Alice Springs to support First Nations children

Fiona Alston

Dec 12, 2025

Court decision a win for services dealing with noise complaints from neighbours

Many early childhood education and care (ECEC) services have, at one time or another, been on the receiving end of a complaint from a neighbour, or group of neighbours, in relation to noise made by children playing in the yards of the service.

Don’t miss a thing

Related topics

Related Articles

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Related Articles

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Don’t miss a thing

Related Articles

High-yielding modern childcare asset in Kelso (Bathurst) listed for sale through CBRE

Expanding access to early education in regional South Australia: New investment brings services closer to families

Stunning Sydney childcare centre sells for $11.5 million

South Australia freehold early learning centre sale: What the Blair Athol deal highlights for ECEC in 2026

Four new kindergartens to open in Greater Geelong in Term 1 2026

Regional confidence: $6.5M sale of Bendigo childcare centre sets the tone for 2026

New public preschools break ground in Macquarie Fields and Ingleburn

Early childhood education assets continue to attract strong investor interest in record-breaking $151m Burgess Rawson from CBRE auction

Community-led early learning service opens in Alice Springs to support First Nations children

Keep Exploring